"Two things can be true. Anthony Volpe is only 24 years old and still has
room to grow as a player. Anthony Volpe was also an overhyped prospect
who has major flaws in his game and might need to be accepted for who he
is."
Point one is Volpe is bad. "Still has room to grow" is an interesting way to put it, but he's just, you know, mostly bad at playing baseball at a major league level.
Point two is Volpe is bad.
"He isn't bad."
He's bad.
"But he also isn't good."
Correct. He isn't good. Which means he is bad.
"Here's the thing, though. Flipping out over Anthony Volpe accomplishes absolutely nothing."
Of course it accomplishes nothing.
Neither does staying calm about Volpe's inabilities to play major league baseball.
Neither does watching baseball or commenting about baseball or scanning the box scores or predicting the future outcomes of baseball games or reminiscing about Jeter and Mariano and Willie and Mickey and the Duke or collecting Aaron Judge Superman bobble head dolls.
It's up to the players to figure out how to play baseball competently.
The fans can do whatever they want.
I wish I had influence on Anthony Volpe's ability to play baseball.
What shall I do? Flip out? Stay calm? Put a Volpe jersey in the freezer? Pray? Maintain a ridiculous blog?
"If fans and media members are still out there complaining about how he
hasn't fulfilled his top prospect pedigree, then they're either in
denial or haven't watched enough baseball."
You aren't saying he's fulfilled his top prospect pedigree, are you?
"Newsflash! So many prospects do not pan out. It's the
unfortunate reality of the sport. It's not Anthony Volpe's fault the
Yankees anointed him the shortstop of the future after just a handful of
games at Triple-A. They put a ton of pressure on him. At times he's lived up to the billing. Most times he's been a disappointment."
Sure.
Of course most prospects do not pan out.
So ... that's it? The fans should just have low expectations and then they won't be disappointed?
I can agree with that, if that's your point.
But that's also not what fans generally choose to do.
"The sooner fans realize Volpe is a solid defender and bottom of the
order bat that can do damage in spurts, the better off everybody will
be. We've written him off as a future cornerstone piece of the organization long ago. That's not a knock on him, either. He has value on this team. He's not
going to turn into what everybody thought he would be just because you
keep yelling about it."
Fan is short for fanatic. You may regulate your emotions as you wish. Others choose to vent.
Also, I WISH Volpe was (a) a solid defender, and (b) THE YANKEES WOULD BAT HIM AT THE BOTTOM OF THE ORDER.
FOR THE LOVE OF ALL THAT IS HOLY, PLEASE STOP BATTING HIM FIFTH. HOW MANY TIMES ARE YOU GOING TO BAT HIM IN THE MIDDLE OF THE ORDER?
Phew.
That felt good.
Another counterpoint: Who is "better off" if the Yankee fans lower their expectations for Volpe?
The fans are better off? Volpe is better off? The Yankees are better off?
Because, while ranting and raving accomplishes nothing in terms of on-field results, blithely accepting incompetence and amateurism from major league baseball players also accomplishes nothing.
"He might become the one everybody envisioned. But chances are he won't.
And that's fine."
It's fine if the Yankee put bad baseball players on the field. Gee. Maybe you just haven't watched enough baseball.
"The Yankees don't need him to be a superstar. They just
need to keep him out of the spotlight and let him find those promising
rhythms, which we've seen plenty of this year."
I have not noticed too many "promising rhythms," but I also wasn't paying attention to his walk up music. Is it Sly and the Family Stone?
It's also a bogus argument: "Volpe doesn't need to be a superstar."
As if that's the problem.
As if he's dazzling us with clutch performances and fundamentally sound play and racking up a nice 30/30 season, but we're just so spoiled that we demand 40 home runs and 100 RBIs.
Volpe has been cut far more slack than any other player I can think of. If the Yankees had sent out Jayson Nix for two-and-a-half years, the fans would be loud and restless.
I agree with keeping Volpe out of the spotlight, I'll grant that much.
The bench is out of the spotlight. Somerset is out of the spotlight. Running errands for Francisco Lindor is out of the spotlight.
"Plus, this entire offense hasn't scored in week. It's not just on Volpe."
Judge was booed, if that makes you feel better.
The booing didn't accomplish anything, but it's just fans doing what they do.