Wednesday, November 28, 2012

Miller was also right about drug testing.

"Professional athletes draw our scorn because they make gobs of money to work a job we say we would do for free. Because some possess a sense of entitlement.

But even the luckiest, richest jerks in the world — the number of which, by the way, is grossly overestimated — deserve the right to choose their place of employment. They ought to receive their fair share of the pie they help create.

...

Don’t espouse the nonsense that players’ greed causes modern ticket prices to be so high. What, you think the owners would keep prices down out of the goodness of their hearts if not for the bloodthirsty players? Please. Pro sports are huge business, and it’s better today for the contributions of Miller, the union’s founding executive director."


Yeah, does anyone ever notice how expensive NBA games are, despite a salary cap?

All players from the steroid era are from the steroid era.

1) Craig Biggio may have taken steroids.

2) Even if he didn't use steroids, his stats benefited from the steroid users who surrounded him:

"All these players spent most of their careers in the era before testing, so we do not really know if they were cheating. But Biggio did not have bulging muscles, so most people assume he was clean. The same could be said of another first-timer, the former pitcher Curt Schilling, who was more stocky than sculptured and was also considered clean.

But assumptions, with varying degrees of evidence, are part of the problem for the hundreds of baseball writers who will cast ballots in this election. Bonds, Clemens, Piazza and Sosa were clearly Hall of Fame-caliber players, yet are widely assumed to have used performance-enhancing drugs. For many writers, even the whiff of such drug use means automatic disqualification."


I think it's a correct observation ... some players get benefit of the doubt, some players don't. But "lack of bulging muscles" is hardly a reasonable test.


"Here is a different question: what if a report surfaced tomorrow with hard evidence that an existing Hall of Famer used steroids? The fantasy of a pure Hall of Fame would be shattered, and the roster of inductees would look confusing with some stars still on the outside."

This will happen soon enough.


"There are no right answers. But it seems most logical to elect the best players and hope that future generations understand the sobering context of the time."


That's probably what I would do.

Tuesday, November 27, 2012

Now he'll get into the Hall of Fame.

"Still, though his contributions to baseball were compared to those of Babe Ruth, who made the home run an essential part of the game, and Branch Rickey, who broke the major leagues’ color barrier when he signed Jackie Robinson to the Brooklyn Dodgers, Mr. Miller has not been recognized by the Baseball Hall of Fame.

'There’s been a concerted attempt to downplay the union,' Mr. Miller told The New York Times, referring to the Hall, when he narrowly missed out on election in December 2010, the fifth time he had been on the ballot. 'It’s been about trying to rewrite history rather than record it. They decided a long time ago that they would downgrade any impact the union has had. And part of that plan was to keep me out of it.' "

I would have loved to have heard his acceptance speech.

The steroid era is back.

I always find it amusing when it's a player such as Carlos Ruiz and no one cares.

Monday, November 19, 2012

Saturday, November 17, 2012

I'll believe it when I see it.

I don't doubt the Blue Jays can be a pretty good team next season, and I also agree that the Forever NY-Bos #1-#2 Punch broke up long ago (even if few noticed).

So the AL East is more competitive than it has been over the past decade and a half.

But I'm simply not impressed Toronto got a bunch of expensive busts from a last place team:

"BEST LINEUP: TORONTO BLUE JAYS

The additions of Jose Reyes and Emilio Bonifacio, who are part of the Jays' haul from Miami, inject speed into a power lineup. Toronto only had slugger Jose Bautista for 92 games last season because of injury, but they still managed to finish fifth in the AL with 198 home runs. Cabrera, who batted .346 last season in San Francisco before serving a 50-game suspension for failing a drug test, gives the Jays a decent on-base threat, assuming he can even approach the .390 OBP he had last year.

Reyes and Cabrera can hit at the top of the order and be followed by Bautista, Encarnacion, Colby Rasmus (23 HRs last year) and potential star Brett Lawrie can bat next and the Jays can expect production from a bottom third of Adam Lind, J.P. Arencibia and Bonifacio.


Reyes is overrated. Bonifacio isn't that good. Melky will be off steroids. Bautista will get hurt again.

After all of these moves, I think the Yankees will probably have the best lineup, best defense, and best bullpen in the AL East next season.

Besides, before you move Toronto into AL East contention, consider the importance of the following: Pitching.

Friday, November 16, 2012

2012 AL MVP

Baseball Writers' Association of America:

I think my friends did a superior job with the AL MVP voting.  Of course, the BBWAA gave one tenth-place vote to platoon player Raul Ibanez and his .240/19/62 season -- the anti-Triple Crown winner.

Name         Points      
Miguel Cabrera362
Mike Trout281
Adrian Beltre210
Robinson Cano149
Josh Hamilton127
Adam Jones120
Derek Jeter77
Justin Verlander58
Prince Fielder56
Yoenis Cespedes41
Edwin Encarnacion33
David Price26
Fernando Rodney24
Jim Johnson22
Alex Rios17
Josh Reddick14
Albert Pujols8
Ben Zobrist7
Joe Mauer6
Rafael Soriano5
Matt Wieters4
Felix Hernanez2
Jered Weaver2
Raul Ibanez1




Felz and his Friends:


Name         Points      
Miguel Cabrera40
Mike Trout27
Josh Hamilton9
Derek Jeter7
Adrian Beltre3
Robinson Cano3
Adam Jones1

2012 NL MVP

Baseball Writers' Association of America:


Name Points
Buster Posey422
Ryan Braun285
Andrew McCutchen245
Yadier Molina241
Chase Headley127
David Wright86
Adam LaRoche86
Craig Kimbrel73
Aramis Ramirez47
Jay Bruce46
Matt Holliday34
Aroldis Chapman20
Brandon Phillips18
Joey Votto16
R.A. Dickey16
Clayton Kershaw15
Ian Desmond15
Michael Bourn12
Allen Craig10
Gio Gonzalez8
Alfonso Soriano8
Kris Medlen8
Martin Prado8
Ryan Zimmerman7
Giancarlo Stanton7
Carlos Beltran6
Aaron Hill6
Carlos Ruiz4
Jason Heyward4
Johnny Cueto2
Bryce Harper2
Chipper Jones1
Miguel Montero1
Angel Pagan1
Hunter Pence1



Felz and his Friends:


Name Points
Buster Posey35
Ryan Braun31
Andrew McCutchen15
David Wright4
Chase Headley2
Joey Votto2
Matt Kemp1

Shenanigans.


"Price won by just four points, 153 to 149, after being placed first on exactly half of the 28 ballots submitted by the writers. Verlander received 13 first-place votes, with the last going, courtesy of the Fort Worth Star-Telegram's Drew Davison, to Rays closer Fernando Rodney, who didn't rank higher than third on any other ballot. That vote alone didn't cost Verlander the award, however, as Davison had Verlander second on his ballot and the difference between first and second place was just three points. What's more, if Davison had ranked Rodney behind both Verlander and Price, it would have given an extra point to Price as well (one point separated second and third places), resulting in a mere two-point gain for Verlander.

The 28 ballots were submitted by two writers from each of the 14 American League markets and the two Angels writers, Michael Martinez of FoxSportsWest.com and Bill Plunkett of the Orange County Register, both put third-place finisher Jered Weaver second on their ballots and Verlander third. They did not cost Verlander the award either, as the difference between second and third place was just one point, so Verlander would only have had two more points if Martinez and Plunkett had flipped Weaver and Verlander on their ballots.

Rather, it took all three ballots to make the difference in the award, so one can't necessarily call shenanigans on the voters."



I call shenanigans because of the typical provincialism.

Like Mark Feinsand over in the NY Daily News pointlessly defending Cabrera over Trout. Not so much of a controversy.

How is Rafael Soriano 8th?

"8. Rafael Soriano, Yankees : Many thought the Yankees’ season was doomed when Mariano Rivera tore his ACL. Soriano had other thoughts."

"Many thought" something and a guy on the Yankees did better than "many thought" he would? That's it? You seriously can think of only 7 players in the entire AL who were more valuable than a replaceable relief pitcher?


Wednesday, November 14, 2012

2012 NL Cy Young

Baseball Writers' Association of America:


Name Points
R.A. Dickey209
Clayton Kershaw96
Gio Gonzalez93
Johnny Cueto75
Craig Kimbrel41
Matt Cain22
Kyle Lohse6
Aroldis Chapman1
Cole Hamels1



Felz and his Friends:


Name Points
R.A. Dickey45
Gio Gonzalez24
Matt Cain12
Johnny Cueto9
Clayton Kershaw7
Aroldis Chapman5
Cole Hamels4
Craig Kimbrel4
Yovani Gallardo1

2012 AL Cy Young

Almost every writer had Price and Verlander in the top two.  Only two writers put Weaver in the top two.  Both of these writers put Weaver second and Verlander third.  Both of these writers are from Los Angeles.


Baseball Writers' Association of America:

Name Points
David Price153
Justin Verlander149
Jered Weaver70
Felix Hernandez41
Fernando Rodney38
Chris Sale17
Jim Johnson5
Mariano Rivera4
Matt Harrison2
Yu Darvish1



Felz and his Friends:


Name Points
Justin Verlander35
David Price31
Jered Weaver26
CC Sabathia7
Phil Hughes4
Felix Hernandez3
Fernando Rodney2
Chris Sale2
Yu Darvish1
Jim Johnson1

Tuesday, November 13, 2012

Props to Robinson Cano.

Robinson Cano becomes a US citizen.

No votes for Bobby Valentine?


1st2nd3rdPoints
Bob Melvin, Athletics1612
116
Buck Showalter, Orioles1216
108
Robin Ventura, White Sox

1212
Joe Maddon, Rays

77
Joe Girardi, Yankees

55
Jim Leyland, Tigers

22
Ron Washington, Rangers

22